Posts Tagged 'Gypsies and Travellers'

Travellers – response to Cllr. Pete West

Below is the text of a letter I had published in the Argus recently:

Cllr. Pete West makes a number of accusations against me and the previous Conservative Administration of Brighton & Hove City Council which I must respond to (Argus letters, 30th June).

Firstly, Cllr. West accuses me of scaremongering over the scale of the problem. Well, if he had checked through the records, as I have done, he would see that this time last year there were precisely zero unauthorised traveller encampments in the city. He should also perhaps talk to the Police who are having to allocate extra dedicated resources to try to manage relations between the settled and traveller communities. This is not scaremongering, it is the reality, and if Cllr. West spent some time talking to residents, he would soon realise this.

Secondly, it is simply not true to say that the previous Administration achieved nothing on travellers for 4 years. We put significant sums of money into refurbishing the Horsdean transit site on two occasions after it was vandalised and this now has space for 23 caravans. I agree with Cllr. West that there is a need for a new permanent site in the city but this will not go anywhere near to solving the problem. As many travellers have stated themselves, they already have permanent bases elsewhere in the country and are not interested in settling here.

And as for political point scoring Cllr. West, it was the Conservative Group who, very early on in your Administration, put in a request to set up a cross-party scrutiny panel to look at solutions to the traveller issue.

Greens need to answer questions on Gypsies and Travellers

Caroline Lucas’s Early Day Motion on Gypsies and Travellers leaves many questions unanswered, not least of which is how it relates to the situation in Brighton & Hove.

1)      She states that “there is no justification for the forced eviction of Gypsies and Travellers where no alternative lawful sites are available and residents seek to live in harmony”. We have an official site in Brighton & Hove – at Horsdean – so perhaps she would like to make a public statement supporting the efforts of the Council and Sussex Police to evict illegal encampments in the City such as those at Black Rock and Wild Park?

2)      Or perhaps she doesn’t think that in Brighton & Hove we have enough “satisfactory and culturally appropriate alternative accommodation” for gypsy and traveller families. In which case, perhaps she could be up front with residents and say exactly where she thinks this should be located in the City.

3)      What exactly does Caroline Lucas mean by seeking to “live in harmony”? I can’t recall ever receiving a single letter or e-mail from a resident welcoming an illegal traveller encampment near their home – perhaps she could enlighten us.

4)      It is certainly true that the children of gypsy and traveller families do significantly worse in terms of education and health outcomes, compared to other families and this is very unfortunate. However, this is not going to be addressed by allowing them to break the law.

5)      Where does Caroline Lucas stand on the issue of van dwellers in Brighton & Hove – in other words, non-ethnic gypsy and travellers who choose to live, unlawfully, on the City’s streets? Does she, for example, agree with the recent judgement at Brighton County Court that the Council was right to seek the eviction of van dwellers at Coldean Lane near the university and that we were not breaching their “human rights” as they had claimed? This is a very live issue in many parts of the City, not least with the summer season approaching and when I tried to raise it at a Council meeting last year, the Greens refused to have a constructive discussion.

As usual with the Greens we get lots of hand-wringing and sloganising but no concrete answers to the problems that residents want us to deal with. Putting forward Early Day Motions is all very laudable but what would they actually do?


council twitterfeed

August 2017
M T W T F S S
« Jul    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031